Showing posts with label johnson. Show all posts
Showing posts with label johnson. Show all posts

Sunday, July 13, 2008

Life of Johnson: Dec. 13, 1784

It is strange, to feel so sad for the death of a man who lived into old age and died in bed 223 years ago. But it is sad; the book so resounds with Boswell's honest love that you cannot help but hear the echo of Johnson's voice, see him in his strange mannerisms, and feel a share of that love yourself. How terrible it is that men die can hardly be imagined, but page by page Boswell manages to put into words the impossible truth that even 1,400 pages seem too few to hold. I almost wish I had not read the book, so painful is it to feel the reality of death.

The last year of his life was marked by great pain, especially from dropsy, a hideous disease, which all but crippled his legs even when it was in remission. He seems to have been treated with the right sort of medicine for one kind of dropsy, since he was given powder of squills, a diuretic herb. He also had opiates to ease the pain, so for the time he was fairly well provided for, but I had a brief physical urge to get him an oxygen tank when he so often could hardly breathe. Even in such pain, "during his sleepless nights he amused himself by translating Latin verse, from the Greek, many of the epigrams in the Anthologia," but as his last year wore on, he regretted that he could no longer even read away his insomnia, saying that on sleepless nights he used to be able to "read like a Turk," which I suppose means lying on his side on cushions.

His last year was spent trying to convalesce in the countryside; he went to his hometown, but found all his remaining friends had died. He then had a wretched year of isolation, seeing no one close to him, and often no one at all. Boswell includes a long series of his letters, which were his sole contact with his former life, and that are highly affecting as the uncomplaining but honestly despairing notes pile up. May it be, that however I die, my last year should not be so utterly alone. And may I also be spared the fate of Boswell, who prostrate with melancholy, failed to write for most of the year, so that after this letter he was only able to get one reply to Johnson before his death:
To James Boswell, Esq
Dear sir, I have this summer sometimes amended, and sometimes relapsed, but, upon the whole, have lost ground, very much. My legs are extremely weak, and my breath very short, and the water [dropsy] is now encreasing upon me. In this uncomfortable state your letters used to relieve; what is the reason that I have them no longer? Are you sick, or are you sullen? Whatever be the reason, if it be less than necessity, drive it away; and of the short life that we have, make the best use for yourself and for your friends....[ellipsis original] I am sometimes afraid that your omission to write has some real cause, and shall be glad to know that you are not sick, and that nothing ill has befallen dear Mrs. Boswell, or any of your family. I am, Sir, your, etc,
Sam. Johnson
How endlessly Boswell must have reproached himself.

As his life dwindled to weeks, he came back to London to die. When a doctor hoped he was feeling better, Johnson said, "No, Sir; you cannot conceive with what acceleration I advance towards death." His friends then were often with him, though his death has a horrifying solitude about it anyway. I suppose death must always be a terrible solitude; even though I picture those who die in bed meeting their end supported by companions, it must be solitary when there is one second that for everyone is followed by another, except for him.

A young woman, the daughter of a close friend, came to ask Johnson's blessing, which proved his last action:
The Doctor turned himself in the bed, and said, "God bless you, my dear!" These were the last words he spoke. His difficulty of breathing increased till about seven o'clock in the evening, when Mr. Barber and Mrs. Desmoulins, who were sitting in the room, observing that the noise he made in breathing had ceased, went to the bed, and found he was dead."

Life of Johnson: Miscellaneous

A few disconnected bits before the last post:

Speaking of Lord Lyttelton's supposed vision of his own death and its occurrence as envisioned, which Johnson had heard from Lyttleton's uncle, he said "It is the most extraordinary thing that has happened in my day... I am so glad to have every evidence of the spiritual world, that I am willing to believe it," and when someone said he should already have enough evidence, he replied, "I like to have more." Several times, Johnson's eagerness for proof of spirits gives Boswell pains to clear him of the charge of superstition. Except when pressed, Johnson often described his fear of death as though it were a fear of damnation, but more proof of a spiritual world could not reassure someone fearing the worst from the spirit world. I take this to be further proof that his true fear was of annihilation.

Johnson told a funny story of human perversity:
You put me in mind of Dr. Barrowby, the physician, who was very fond of swine's flesh. One day, when he was eating it, he said, "I wish I was a Jew." "Why so? (said somebody;) the Jews are not allowed to eat your favorite meat." "Because, (said he, ) I should then have the gust of eating it, with the pleasure of sinning."
While discussing whether life was "upon the whole more happy or miserable," Johnson argued for misery and Boswell added the argument, "that no man would choose to lead over again the life which he had experienced." Boswell says, "Johnson acceded to that opinion in the strongest terms." I agree too, except that if I could go back with the knowledge I now have, I would risk it, though with not a lot of optimism. However, Burke argued for happiness:
Every man would lead his life over again; for every man is willing to go on and take an addition to his life, which, as he grows older, he has no reason to think will be better, or even so good as what has preceded.
Boswell blames false hope, and quotes the first line from the elegy Johnson wrote for the strange lower-class doctor who lived with him for decades. Here is the whole first stanza:
Condemn'd to Hope's delusive mine,
As on we toil from day to day,
By sudden blasts or slow decline
Our social comforts drop away.
He also quotes Dryden, who is much more on point:
When I consider life, 'tis all a cheat,
Yet fool'd with hope, men favor the deceit:
Trust on, and think tomorrow will repay;
Tomorrow's falser than the former day;
Lies worse; and while it says we shall be blest
With some new joys, cuts off what we possest.
Strange cozenage! none would live past years again;
Yet all hope pleasure in what yet remain;
And from the dregs of life think to receive
What the first sprightly running could not give

Friday, July 11, 2008

Life of Johnson: Reading

Boswell says Johnson was not a croaker, one who complains about his age in all ways. Johnson found his age very pleasing, except that "subordination is sadly broken down in this age." The Tory Telegraph still makes the same complaint, but calls it "lack of deference." Johnson does twice say that reading had declined, once in reference to lawyers' preparation and I think to doctors the other time, but it seems he only thought more training was now acquired in conversation than formerly.

In keeping with the Johnsonian spirit, I should make it clear that I would not choose any other age, all the others being poor in knowledge and menaced by torturers going by the name of physicians. Scientific advances have been an increasing proportion of each century's glories from the 16th, but this age has seen science become unearthly in its glory and beauty. Medicine has become powerful too, and it is an everyday thing for a sick man to be told, "Take up your bed and walk." My grandmother just had a knee entirely replaced, and the other will be done in a few months; she will travel to Italy this year. Johnson tried hard to get to Italy in his final year, hoping the better climate would help, but his too-helpful band of doctors could not make him well enough.

There are many other wonderful things about this age, among them that basic literacy and some degree of knowledge belong to more people than ever before. My earlier complaint is more specific: that group, never large, of people who can attain to significant knowledge and true literacy is now afflicted with the delusion that those attainments are at best private games and at worst sabotage of the efficient machines that will create heaven on Earth. Since Dewey's fools have come to the worst conclusion, the result has been that every year's births provide the raw materials for an educational system more perfectly stripped of knowledge than the year before. If you happen to be one of those industrial inputs, but are somehow so badly machined that you end up with some part of a humane education, you will find that the other inputs, having stayed on the assembly line, can no more understand your peculiarity than a BMW could see the point of a horse. People are not more stupid now than before--they may even be smarter, and many become powerful engines of science--but even with smart listeners, the whole of life cannot be conversations in the form of lectures starting at first principles.

Even highly esteemed graduate schools in the humanities have little to work with, though they do their best by drawing from overseas and from private schools. It is painful to listen to professors talk and to realize that you are witnessing the descent of man; in classics, the greatest scholars are all past retirement, and many are over 80. They have been great from their early days, as I found whenever I read their published work, though of course they have grown more learned over time. Professors of 50, unless they were educated entirely overseas, have little of the older generation's penetration, but are serviceable: hammers, not lances. Professors of 40 show astonishing gaps in their knowledge, and professors of 30 sometimes seem never to have opened a book from outside their field or this year's NYT bestsellers list. American graduate students in their mid-20s, though their native talents may be great, would have been rejected by undergraduate admissions fifty years ago for appalling unpreparedness. All of this refers to Americans educated in public schools and most private schools; the rest of the world was not so stupid as to admire Dewey.

So imagine being an American of 30 or 35 but by ill chance possessed of a mind roughly molded in the older style. As you look far ahead to those nearing death, you see scholars who utterly outstrip you; looking ever closer, you find people more and more like you, though more finely modeled; somewhere around 50, they grow more alien; when you look behind at those coming up, you realize that their principles of thought are becoming not only alien but hostile, fused with political ideology. Every year the desolation, like the Sahara, increases its borders a little more, but also adds more savages who only know the wasteland. They love the wasteland; men love the manner of life to which they are born, and resent attempts to unearth and tear up its radical errors. All this is not pleasant now; it will be intolerable in thirty years, when the wasteland covers everything and only scattered anchorites remember what was lost.

Johnson would surely not believe the extent of the collapse, but he would understand how reading might die, once learning was no longer esteemed or profitable, and other entertainment was cheap and ubiquitous:
It is strange that there should be so little reading in the world, and so much writing. People in general do not willingly read, if they can have any thing else to amuse them. There must be an external impulse; emulation, or vanity, or avarice. The progress which the understanding makes through a book, has more pain than pleasure in it. Language is scanty, and inadequate to express the nice gradations and mixtures of our feelings. No man reads a book of science from pure inclination. The books that we do read with pleasure are light compositions, which contain a quick succession of events.

Wednesday, July 9, 2008

Life of Johnson: Cats

I used up my writing time with that last post, but how can I not write about Johnson and cats. Boswell writes,
Nor would it be just...to omit the fondness which he shewed for animals which he had taken under his protection. I never shall forget the indulgence with which he treated Hodge, his cat: for whom he himself used to go out and buy oysters, lest the servants having that trouble should take a dislike to the poor creature.
He also let Hodge climb up on his chest, which upset Boswell the cat-hater. On another occasion, Johnson was talking of a loony young nobleman who was "running about town shooting cats"; falling then into a "sort of kindly reverie, he bethought himself of his own favorite cat, and said, 'But Hodge shan't be shot; no, no Hodge shall not be shot.'" What a sweet image that is, and the most tenderness I remember seeing an Englishman express towards an animal before the 20th century.

I also now want to call a cat Hodge, but my Dinah could never learn to ignore a new name so perfectly.

Tuesday, July 8, 2008

Life of Johnson: Americans and the end of the war

So my interest in seeing Johnson thwarted by American victory is not to be satisfied. He says almost nothing, only expressing his relief when the administration that lost the war was replaced. It seems it had an effect on him though, for he says twice to Boswell that he no longer enjoys talking about current politics; in 1783 he says, "I'd as soon have a man to break all my bones as talk to me of public affairs, internal or external. I have lived to see all things as bad as they can be." I am a little sorry for him; the American victory began the utter defeat of his kind of Toryism, though after the rapid losses from that day to the mid-19th century it took another century for old Toryism to be extinguished entirely. The fissioning of the Anglican communion, which is happening right now in the split Lambeth and FUCA conferences, shows how far things have changed from the days of loyalty to Church and Crown, but how the forms still linger.

The Anglican problems, which were caused by the theological novelties of the North American Anglicans (Episcopalians) and of the Archbishop of Canterbury, Rowan Williams, remind me of what Johnson said about freedom of religion: "Every man has a right to utter what he thinks truth, and every other man has a right to knock him down for it. Martyrdom is the test." It seems the gay bishop thinks much the same.

I promised to return to Taxation No Tyranny, but there is not a lot there; I think Boswell is right that it is largely bluster and sophistry. But there are two interesting arguments. The first is a familiar one; if the state's power of coercion is an affront to liberty, then there must either be anarchy or tyranny. He does not give theoretical grounds for believing the state will not become tyrannous, even though he values the power of coercion over individual liberty, but then again no one has found a theoretical basis for valuing liberty over government power that does not lead at least some enthusiasts to anarchy. What he ought to give is a discussion of the mechanisms by which the emphasis can shift back and forth between state power and liberty. He could then argue that the American revolts were a disruption of those processes and that giving in to them would make the damage irreparable. His desire to give colonies no quarter and to reserve all powers to the parent state makes that impossible though. His views remind me of Hobbes, though I do not remember a reference to him and the index does not have anything useful.

The other interesting argument still causes trouble today. Johnson spends several paragraphs on a mock Declaration of Independence by Cornwall, which because of their independent linguistic and ethnic background as Celts he considers a stronger case than the Americans make. The underlying argument is the same one used against Woodrow Wilson's puffy idealism: if any people desiring a state must have one, who can be refused a state? Soon enough all states will the size of Lichtenstein, if long tenure imposes no limits on secessions because of historical grievances or ethnic identities. A cruelly oppressed people might safely be granted that right without risking general secession, except that the colonists managed to convince themselves they were cruelly oppressed when they were really governed lightly. It is embarrassing how extravagant the complaints were when the offenses were so much less than everyday federal actions now. What makes more sense is that a people should form a separate state when it has become numerous and prosperous and has shown an effective and beneficial ability to govern itself. That is not as exciting as sic semper tyrannis and other bloody slogans, and of course men of good will and intelligence can agree on a principle like that yet bitterly disagree that it applies to any particular instance. Still, it is no way out, to try to make the whole problem disappear into the primacy of the Crown.

Wednesday, July 2, 2008

Johnson: Going for a roll

What with cleaning and yardwork in preparation for the 4th, I have not made much progress, though I am down to the last 200 pages or so. Boswell's depiction is so detailed and affectionate that I actually feel sad as the end approaches. How could anyone read the Life and not come out loving Johnson? Even the way he sometimes makes me think of Ignatius Reilly is in the end charming. Apparently Boswell censored some of Johnson's low humor, which is both a surprise, given what he included, and a shame, since the way Johnson told low jokes would have to show a lot about him. I was just going to say that Johnson was very dignified, but though he often was, he could also be wonderfully goofy. Once, in his 50s or 60s, when he came to a grassy hill, he said something like "I haven't been for a roll in a long time," and rolled down the hill. Another time, in his late 40s or early 50s, he got talked into staying out all night drinking and running around, and when morning came he and a friend went out boating I think, and made fun of Boswell for being too responsible to come. Boswell does not give enough of that sort of thing for me to have a feel for how that playfulness fitted in with the rest of his personality, but at any rate it is very appealing.

Monday, June 30, 2008

Why read?

Reading must often feel a useless indulgence. Unless you are part of the society of authors and scholars, you will rarely have the satisfaction and improved understanding that come from dissecting a work in conversation. Nor does reading bring any significant amount of praise or even recognition, since with so few now reading, you will meet hardly anyone who knows how Rasselas differs from Tuesdays with Morrie, or that one book even can differ in any meaningful way from another. Nearly all think of reading as nothing but a hobby, increasingly rare and in its more serious form simply eccentric. Worse, what little recognition there is for reading belongs to those who read, or at least flatter with the pretense of reading, the latest profitless works of trendy literature or radical politics. When someone says he is a reader, hide your own reading or risk having to fight your way out of the conversation when he starts to praise some House of Sand and Fog or Hegemony or Survival. It is even more depressing when the reader turns out to read only books on personal finances (men) or self-help (women); they look on books as mere stuff to line their material lives, not readers but paper wasps.

As it happens, reading good books is of private advantage; it is difficult to prove to doubters why this should be, but once acquired a well-stocked mind reconciles a man to life. By contrast, Theodore Dalrymple described the self-destroying pain of those who reach their 30s without internal resource, just as the delusory significance of youth fades. Still I would like to believe that these strange electrical whorls, that for the moment fill my mind but soon enough will uncoil and go dark, have some kind of purpose outside myself. Johnson's essay in the Adventurer, issue 85, gives no proofs, but offers wonderful reassurance.
An opinion has of late been, I know not how, propagated among us, that libraries are filled only with useless lumber; that men of parts stand in need of no assistance; and that to spend life in poring upon books, is only to imbibe prejudices, to obstruct and embarrass the powers of nature, to cultivate memory at the expense of judgment, and to bury reason under a chaos of indigested learning.
Astounding that at the very dawn of the modern age, Rousseau's foolishness had already spread generally. Johnson might as well be responding to a modern pedagogical statement on the value of critical thinking over "rote learning." His next argument has by now been made often, but it is delightful to hear how he says it:
If reason has the power ascribed to it by its advocates, if so much is to be discovered by attention and meditation, it is hard to believe, that so many millions, equally participating of the bounties of nature with ourselves, have been for ages upon ages meditating in vain: if the wits of the present time expect the regard of posterity, which will then inherit the reason which is now thought superior to instruction, surely they may allow themselves to be instructed by the reason of former generations. When, therefore, an author declares, that he has been able to learn nothing from the writings of his predecessors, and such a declaration has been lately made, nothing but a degree of arrogance unpardonable in the greatest human understanding, can hinder him from perceiving that he is raising prejudices against his own performance; for with what hopes of success can he attempt that in which greater abilities have hitherto miscarried? or with what peculiar force does he suppose himself invigorated, that difficulties hitherto invincible should give way before him?
Johnson comes now to the part that, even if I can see how the sentence I italicized is only assertion, still warms me with reassurance:
Of those whom Providence has qualified to make any additions to human knowledge, the number is extremely small; and what can be added by each single mind, even of this superior class, is very little: the greatest part of mankind must owe all their knowledge, and all must owe far the larger part of it, to the information of others. To understand the works of celebrated authors, to comprehend their systems, and retain their reasonings, is a task more than equal to common intellects; and he is by no means to be accounted useless or idle, who has stored his mind with acquired knowledge, and can detail it occasionally to others who have less leisure or weaker abilities.
I wonder though, what Johnson would say to those of us whose minds fall between the discoverers of new knowledge and the common intellects, in an age when the common intellects are little interested in new knowledge and wholly uninterested in anything old. To live in an age of ignorance has the selfish advantage of making even modest minds seem great, to themselves, for merely attempting what was once required of young students. It is not a very satisfying feeling though.

If I have dwelt on the unhappiness of having no public benefit in reading, still Johnson goes on to say much the same thing:
Persius has justly observed, that knowledge is nothing to him who is not known by others to possess it [Scire tuum nihil est, nisi te scire hoc sciat alter: your knowledge is nothing, unless another knows of your knowledge.]: to the scholar himself it is nothing with respect either to honor or advantage, for the world cannot reward those qualities which are concealed from it; with respect to others it is nothing, because it affords no help to ignorance or errour.
He goes on to recommend that scholars cultivate skill in conversation, to make their knowledge of public use and honor, and to practice writing, so that their scholarship and their conversation are both made more exact. What, though, would Johnson say is to be done, when there is not conversation to be had, nor many readers to be found for writing?

To write a blog, praise myself, and take another swig from the bitter cup of learning, I expect.

Friday, June 27, 2008

Life of Johnson: Americans

Johnson bitterly hated America and was violent on the subject of the tax protests, even before the revolution. He wrote a long pamphlet against the tax protests, called Taxation No Tyranny, which Boswell, who favored the American complaints, said was largely bluster and sophistries. From my first read, it seems he had a theory of apostolic succession in government, so that once a proper government was formed, all subsequent alterations and branches derived their authority from the original, or else had no authority at all. I have never heard that before, so I want to think about it more.

Otherwise, he has not made many interesting arguments. He wastes time on the straw man that Americans were opposed to taxation itself, though he admits they granted the theoretical right of taxation. Much later he addresses the real question, of taxation without representation, making the expected argument that the colonists are included in parliamentary representation as much as all the other groups of people who have no direct vote. He does not appear to realize that those other groups might well deserve representation as well. He even uses the existence of rotten boroughs, unrepresented cities, and the small electorate as arguments against the idea that every region deserves representation. In a way, the thread of his thought does resemble what later happened, with America splitting away, then the formation of legislatures in Canada in 1791, the reform of rotten boroughs in 1831 and again in 1867, the grant of representation to cities founded in modern times in 1832, and the extension of suffrage in 1832.

He adds that the original colonists had the potential (though few the actual ability) to vote before they left England, so their departure was a voluntary abandonment of the right to vote. I suppose that is true, though it seems more likely that they abandoned voting on practical rather than theoretical grounds. In any case, why would that original choice to abandon the vote descend from those few original settlers to the three million Americans of 1778, in their large(ish) cities governed by assemblies? They had no practical ability to move to England, and the original condition of the settlers, of small armed camps in the wild, with little need for representation in England, did not resemble the young commercial states, with their frequent and complex interaction with England.

He did suggest that the "planters," which I hope does not mean only the Southern plantation owners whose slave-owning he elsewhere condemned, could have bought large estates in England, which would have given them the vote and potentially seats in parliament. That idea was not very practical, given the danger and distance that had prevented trans-Atlantic land holding for two centuries, and again revealed how little he cared whether representation was distributed unevenly. That method would have made a small group of self-selected wealthy men the sole representatives of the colonies, without recourse for the rest of the colonists.

He argues that royal charters to the colonies can be amended at will by the king or parliament, without appeal by the colonies, while the colonies are not allowed to point to long-standing usage to prove their rights. In a way, that grants the colonists' argument, that parliament and the king were beginning to strip the colonies of their traditional rights, and that to grant the power of taxation without representation was to put all freedoms at the whim of the king. He does not mention it, but the colonists were also greatly exercised by the thought that religious restrictions would follow on taxation, with the appointment of bishops from England and the enforcement of Anglicanism as the state religion.

The pamphlet was written in 1775; it is surprising how little Johnson mentions the war afterward, even in 1778. Since he and Boswell fight so bitterly on the subject that they stop seeing each other for a while, more than once, perhaps his lack of comment is only tact on his or Boswell's part. Still, he does not mention the war in letters to others. Only with Gen. Burgoyne's defeat does war news in the ordinary sense break in.

Wednesday, June 25, 2008

Life of Johnson: More wine

Boswell says that Johnson could only abstain completely or drink (or eat) too much, though when he drank too much it was in private. His explanation for drinking to excess in private is all too understandable:
Johnson: I require wine, only when I am alone. I have then often wished for it, and often taken it.
Spottiswoode: What, by way of a companion, sir?
Johnson: To get rid of myself, to send myself away.
He adds that "wine makes a man better pleased with himself," though often less pleasing to others, and adds a reason that explains why, if I have to go to a party, I go straight for a beer:
Wine gives a man nothing. It neither gives him knowledge nor wit; it only animates a man, and enables him to bring out what a dread of the company has repressed. It only puts in motion what has been locked up in frost.
He adds, "this may be good, or it may be bad," but when the alternative is a frosty lack of ease, I am willing to risk the bad. Boswell in this sense acted on Johnson like wine, prompting him to talk freely, even posing inane questions just to stir Johnson into action. Another friend said of Johnson that he was like a ghost, only speaking when spoken to. I did not know that ghosts were like that, but it shows how generally silent Johnson was without the influence of wine or Boswell. When Johnson said, "A man should cultivate his mind so as to have that confidence and readiness without wine, which wine gives," I think it is a worthy sentiment that nevertheless represents Johnson's hope for himself, not his actual behavior. He was a great one for resolutions, even long into old age, despite recognizing that men achieved little with resolutions. If Johnson's astoundingly cultivated mind could not break the ice dam without help, regardless of his resolutions, I think that disability must be intrinsic to certain minds. In much company, too, the ability to take equal part in conversation decreases with greater cultivation.

Though it does not mean much, it is funny that when he was a "water-drinker," Johnson "supposed every body who drank wine to be elevated," that is, plastered. I would also like to know whether "wine" in all these discussions means only wine, or includes spirits and beer, since they go unmentioned. The details (cellars, vintages, bumpers) are all of wine, but it is odd not to hear anything at all about the others, especially since one of Johnson's great friends, Mr. Thrale, was a wealthy brewer.

Tuesday, June 24, 2008

Life of Johnson: Wine

Without thinking about it, I started drinking late, have only drunk too much a handful of times, and on the whole prefer not drinking, nor has any stronger drug tempted me, even when offered. When people find out, usually while swapping drug stories, they hardly believe it is not from some excess of religion. I rarely explain, because it is somehow embarrassing to admit the sole reason, that thinking clearly makes me happy, and thinking muddily makes me unhappy, which is what Johnson, who for a few years drank too much, felt too:
[I left off drinking wine] because it is so much better for a man to be sure that he is never to be intoxicated, never to lose the power over himself. I shall not begin to drink wine again, till I grow old, and want it... It is a diminution of pleasure, to be sure; but I do not say a diminution of happiness. There is more happiness in being rational... Supposing we could have pleasure always, an intellectual man would not compound for it. The greatest part of men would compound, because the greatest part of men are gross.
(He was 69 when he said that; "till I grow old" must mean very great age. Also "to compound for" means "to settle for," so to exchange happiness for pleasure.) It is probably relevant that Johnson had a painful fear of madness, which I share; that fear is the fear of "losing the power over himself." He also greatly feared annihilation: "No rational man can die without uneasy apprehension" and "It is in the apprehension of it that the horror of annihilation consists." It does not create happiness, to pull the shades and dim the lights when daylight is so brief, twilight so gray, and night so empty.

Sunday, June 22, 2008

Rev. Dodd

The case of William Dodd is very strange. He lived in the absurd style called maccaroni, even though he was a clergyman, and even more oddly achieved great popularity for his preaching, which I would have thought at odds with his unpopular fashion. His luxurious life far exceeded his real means, and in time he forged a note for the enormous sum of 4,200 pounds, which at a minimum would be $400,000 in present money. He was gently punished by public hanging.

Johnson tried hard to have Dodd's sentence commuted to transportation, even going so far as to write Dodd's final address to be delivered in Dodd's name. Dodd showed the same thoughtless, self-centered character to the very end, not bothering to let the world know what papers Johnson had written for him, even after it could no longer harm his cause to let it be known; that selfish omission very much bothered Johnson later. The ludicrous reverend did at least write Johnson a letter of thanks, though crammed with emphases (italics in print, maybe underlining in the original?) and exclamation points, far beyond what mere impending death could justify. (When writing the night before being hanged, the number of exclamation points granted is double that of the next highest allotment, the announcement of the birth of one's first child, so, two per page. But a good man will not abuse that license.) Had Dodd lived in the age of email, his final note would have been scarcely visible through the crowd of upset faces. Apart from his regrettable style, though hanging is a brutal punishment for forgery, Dodd comes across as a very creepy and hypocritical man, whose absence would have to improve the world. Johnson in fact only argues that Dodd be made to disappear by transportation to the most distant colony available.

Johnson, in his final letter to Dodd, makes a surprisingly callous argument:
Be comforted: your crime, morally or religiously considered, has no very deep dye of turpitude. It corrupted no man's principles; it attacked no man's life. It involved only a temporary and reparable injury.
But this was in an age when arrest and imprisonment for debt was so routine that Johnson himself once was saved from arrest only by an immediate payment from a friend. The sum of money was so large that the man who paid out on the forged bond must have risked bankruptcy, since Dodd squandered the money and the nobleman whose name had been forged preferred to prosecute Dodd rather than pay. Bankruptcy then did not mean several years of unpleasantness and some embarrassment, but utter collapse of life and probably imprisonment, during which the man's wife and children would have no protection except for the meager help afforded to paupers. The saintly Dodd may well have done less harm just to stab a man and take his purse, though a common mugging may not have commanded such public support. To be fair to Johnson, it is of course possible that the bond purchaser was so extraordinarily rich that he could absorb even so large a loss; neither Boswell nor wikipedia describe the purchaser.

Johnson was not opposed to trade and famously said "a man is seldom so innocently employed as when he is getting money," but he also said, of a man who had shot a Scottish nobleman in self-defense but was convicted anyway, that a commoner has no honor to defend. Clergy were often noble, and bishops were honorary lords; Johnson seems to treat all clergy as honorary minor gentry at least. A banker or money-lender would not have that distinction, even though Johnson would have no special prejudice against them. It is hard to follow the thought of a man who could be passionately against slavery, when that position was still uncommon, but just as passionately for the subservience of nearly all men to a few.

Life of Johnson: Death

Johnson had a peculiarly intense fear of dying. If Boswell brought up the subject of death, he grew agitated and if pressed farther was hardly able to speak and was physically affected as well. It was not very kind of Boswell to upset Johnson so more than once; he admits it himself. Still, the experience let Boswell give this wonderful description of Johnson's fears:
His mind resembled the vast amphitheater, the Coliseum at Rome. In the center stood his judgment, which, like a mighty gladiator, combated those apprehensions that, like the wild beasts of the Arena, were all around in cells, ready to be let out upon him. After the conflict, he drove them back into their dens; but not killing them, they were still assailing him.
I wish I had learned earlier that, though different people have different wild beasts of the mind, it is true for everyone that most of the beasts can never be killed; only in the last few years did I realize, to continue the metaphor, that the nearest thing to victory is to learn the special tricks to send each beast crawling back to its den with the least combat.

On another occasion (like the first, provoked by Hume's carelessness of death), Johnson says that "he never had a moment in which death was not terrible to him." He adds, "The better a man is, the more afraid he is of death, having a clearer view of infinite purity." I think he means, a better man knows better how far he falls short of perfection, and so knows better how he deserves damnation. Boswell elsewhere does say he thought Johnson's fear to be not of dying, but of what came after. Still, it was talk of death that upset Johnson, not talk of the afterlife.

When Boswell asks, "Is not the fear of death natural to man?" Johnson answers, "So much so that the whole of life is but keeping away the thoughts of it." He feared for his conduct on his deathbed and wondered, "I know not whether I should wish to have a friend by me, or have it all between God and myself." As with his drinking, even in the greatest pain he wished no one to see him fail in right conduct. I recently experienced this ranking of shame above pain when I went in for some neurological testing related to a long illness. The tests, which return immediate results, had a significant chance of finding that I had a progressive illness that would soon cripple and in a decade or two kill me. A sweet-natured friend wanted very much to drive for me, and I found myself asking a question much like Johnson's. In the end I asked my brother to come, since someone had to and there is less shame in going to pieces in front of a brother. As it happens, the tests returned good results, but I would make the same choice again. The experience of keeping composure under considerable strain makes me more easily believe Johnson's observation that "scarce any man dies in public, but with apparent resolution; from that desire of praise which never quits us." Of course that was the last century of frequent public executions in England, so the observation would not be merely speculative.

By the way, I am not giving page numbers because if you search for any phrase from a quotation (you may have to convert it back to British spelling) you will turn up the right page on books.google.com. Also, the page numbers on the Google books editions are not at all similar.

Thursday, June 19, 2008

Life of Johnson: Economics

Johnson's economic beliefs are interesting. For instance, when Boswell asks, "Would it be for the advantage of a country that all its lands were sold at once?" Johnson responds, "So far as money produces good, it would be an advantage; for then that country would have as much money circulating in it as it is worth." On the one hand, he recognizes the value of a ready supply of capital, but on the other, he clearly believed in the land theory of value. Smith himself believed in the labor theory of value; the idea that value means nothing but the value assigned by men came much later.

Johnson later makes a statement that would please an economist of the Austrian school: defending a wealthy woman who made a show of her highly effective charity, he said "I have seen no beings who do as much good from benevolence, as she does, from whatever motive... To act from pure benevolence is not possible for finite beings. Human benevolence is mingled with vanity, interest, or some other motive." Of course they go farther; my economics professor would have put it, "Human benevolence is inseparable from vanity, interest, or some other motive." But he would have agreed with Johnson's conclusion: the effect is still good and deserves praise.

I am not sure what to make of this quotation: "As to mere wealth, that is to say, money, it is clear that one nation or one individual cannot increase its store but by making another poorer: but trade procures what is more valuable, the reciprocation of the peculiar advantages of different countries." It may mean that Johnson thought all economic growth was zero-sum, or that hard money, being inherently limited in supply, must move around rather than increase or decrease. That would imply deflation and inflation as real economic worth changed. I think he does mean that the sizes of economies are zero-sum, but his recognition of competitive advantage, which he sees increases real wealth independently of currency supply, makes it unclear.

Nearing page 800. Boswell is suddenly taking multiple pages per day; he says at the start that he wishes he met Johnson earlier, but would anyone have ever read the 15,000 page book that would have resulted?

Wednesday, June 18, 2008

Life of Johnson: Happiness and laughter

Everything Johnson says about happiness and depression convinces me, almost painfully. I am reading his Life now because I read his Rasselas last year. It is an almost classical form of philosophy, an investigation of happiness through a dialogue, and beautifully lucid.

Pope's Essay on Man is also wonderful, though I scarcely remember anything more than that. Boswell has Johnson commenting on Pope's line,

[Hope springs eternal in the human breast:]
Man never is, but always to be blest.

Boswell writes, "[Johnson] asserted that the present was never a happy state to any human being; but that, as every part of life, of which we are conscious, was at some point of time a period yet to come, in which felicity was expected, there was some happiness produced by hope." Further, that man is happy in the moment, "Never, but when he is drunk." In one of his prefaces, Boswell says he thinks Johnson underestimated man's potential for happiness because of his melancholy. With charming guilelessness, Boswell says he is sure he has had more happiness out of life than Johnson did; Boswell was something of a wencher and a wine-bibber. Johnson must be overstating in any case, or Boswell misunderstanding, because the first assertion means that men are sometimes happy in the present, though that happiness properly belongs to their future self, whose state is the cause of the happiness.

Hope is happiness and despair, not a lack of pleasant feelings, is the opposite of happiness. I wonder what Johnson would think of the idea that there is a second happiness, also not in the present. When long-held hopes are worked towards and then achieved, they leave happy memories, even if at the time there was no real happiness. So people are happy in the memory of rearing children, in remembering that they have acted rightly, in having been to school, in having achieved a career, in short in all kinds of things that while still in progress cause too much strain and work to produce a sensation of happiness.

Recent attempts to develop a scientific understanding of happiness have emphasized that our minds can only dimly imagine the future and more imagine than remember the past. We therefore choose paths unlikely to take us to happiness. There is some science to it, but it is mostly a rhetorical trick. The argument is that remembered happiness, being inaccurate, does not count, or counts for much less; with remembered happiness not counting, it is easy enough to show that gaining some hoped-for state brings much less happiness than expected, and thus that the hope itself was mistaken. But why should remembered happiness not count? It is hardly relevant that my memories are not a bald factual account; they are the only sort of memories available to me. Neither can I implant wholly delusional memories as a shortcut to happiness. If I had the mind of a computer, I would be irrational to have the hopes I do, for they have such difficulties in them that to remember every detail would be intolerable. Having the mind of a man, I have every reason to expect that some of the great satisfactions of mankind will be mine as well. But I think the new science of happiness does successfully describe why pursuing happiness through new toys and entertainments is delusional.

Johnson was not as gloomy as it might seem; even while depressed he was good-natured and enjoyed wit and conversation. Sometimes, when the depression lifted, he would be in a "humour for jocularity and merriment," and would laugh often, "a kind of good humoured growl." Boswell quotes another's description of it: "He laughs like a rhinoceros." A good laugh is such a delight. I have a great-uncle whose sweet-natured, quiet, almost rumbling chuckle, which makes the skin under his chin wobble, is one of the great pleasures of knowing him. Strange but wonderful laughs seem to run on that side of the family; my grandmother, his sister, has a sweet, girlish laugh even in her seventies. Her son, my uncle, had a short, odd laugh that was very endearing, especially with the motion of his prodigious gray eyebrows emphasizing his pleasure. He died a year ago, and even though there was much more about him to miss, how sad it is that while the good he did may be remembered, no one will ever hear his laugh again, and in time it will be forgotten.

I first wrote that this would be divine vandalism, if there were divinity, but that makes little sense and is probably pose. If there are two archons battling across creation, one making, one destroying, then it makes sense to call one a vandal, or maybe it just drowns nonsense in a sea of absurdity. If there is a god as described in Bible, in either Testament, then this sort of thing is merely unintelligible, the actions of a creator who labors over small delights but soon smashes them. Paul says,
Will what is molded say to its molder, "Why have you made me like this?" Has the potter no right over the clay, to make out of the same lump one vessel for honorable use and another for dishonorable use? (Rom. 9:20-21)
The potter may make and smash as he wills. If the Bible did not say it, no one would ever have guessed that so capricious a creator could be said to love what he treats so lightly.

Tuesday, June 17, 2008

Life of Johnson: Germs, happiness, the Scots

Still in a dull-ish part, but here are some quotations I would like to remember.

Kenneth Macaulay (great-uncle of Thomas Macaulay, the Whig historian who so savaged Croker) wrote a history of St. Kilda, a very isolated island, in which he included a "wonderful story that upon the approach of a stranger all the inhabitants catch cold." Someone told him to leave it out; Johnson praised him for leaving it in: "To leave things out of a book, merely because people tell you they will not be believed, is meanness. Macaulay acted with more magnanimity." It has been a given for centuries that a man should tell the truth even when he will be attacked for it, which helps encourage honest men to do just that, but I at least had never thought how especially hard it can be to tell the truth when the reaction will simply be disbelief. I like the contrast of meanness and magnanimity, which says that a great-souled man knows the world to be so large that its oddities will exceed his own knowledge and that it is timidity to conceal them. The story was also likely true; it is explained elsewhere that the islanders rarely had ships visit, so for someone who knows about germ theory, it is easy to believe that each visit was a new exposure to diseases from the mainland.

Johnson, who persevered through life-long depression, said this about climate, which seemed directed towards me and my complaints about Seattle's gloom: "What is climate to happiness? Place me in the heart of Asia, should I not be exiled? What proportion does climate bear to the complex system of human life? You may advise me to go to live at Bologna to eat sausages. The sausages there are the best in the world; they lose much by being carried." Still, there is no denying that one of Seattle's rare sunny days lifts my spirits.

Johnson did not think much of the Scots, or at least he had some prejudice that he enjoyed using to tease Boswell. Johnson's critical acumen led him to reject the supposedly ancient Scottish poem Fingal, which had in fact been largely forged. In a letter to Boswell, speaking of the discoverer/forger's claim to have manuscripts (which he never produced), Johnson said, "If old manuscripts should now be mentioned, I should, unless there were more evidence than can be easily had, supposed them another proof of Scotch conspiracy in national falsehood. Do not censure the expression; you know it to be true." I happened to see a book (The Invention of Scotland: Myth and History) on the same topic, in the Telegraph I think, just last week; I would like to read it. Anyway, it is not a peculiar vice of the Scots, but a common disease of weak and resentful nations. Germany, Russia, Japan, Ireland, and most recently Mexico have all succumbed to it. I suppose multiculturalism prohibits the observation that men often lie to further a common delusion and that few delusions are as gripping as mystical nationalism.

Monday, June 16, 2008

Life of Johnson, I

Though as I start this blog I am 600 pages through Boswell's Life of Johnson, and the great man is already 66, there are still about 700 pages to go, so no harm done. Also I have just been reading the years around the trip to Scotland, which are very boring, the interesting parts all having been written into Boswell's Journal of a Tour to the Hebrides and Johnson's Journey to the Western Islands of Scotland, so this post will not even be about the Life.

Before starting the book, I read Macaulay's review of Croker's edition. It is not much of an encouragement to read the book, but it is pretty funny. Macaulay starts off softly, with the first sentence: "This work has greatly disappointed us." From there he goes into a little warm-up routine. "This edition is ill compiled, ill arranged, ill written, and ill printed." A little farther on: "The tomes absolutely swarm with misstatements into which the editor never would have fallen, if he had taken the slightest pains to investigate the truth of his assertions, or if he had even been well acquainted with the book on which he undertook to comment." He accuses Croker of gross ignorance and negligence akin to medical malpractice, compares Croker to schoolgirls to his disadvantage and repeatedly fantasizes about lashing him as a schoolmaster would a pig-headed little boy.

Having now warmed up, Macaulay goes for a touch directly on Croker's class: "A very large proportion of the two thousand five hundred notes which the editor boasts of having added... remind us of nothing so much as of those profound and interesting annotations which are pencilled by sempstresses and apothecaries' boys on the dog-eared margins of novels borrowed from circulating libraries; 'How beautiful!' 'Cursed prosy!' 'I don't like Sir Reginald Malcolm at all.' 'I think Pelham is a sad dandy.'"

Croker does sound like an idiot, and only a very small number of his comments survive in the 1953 OUP edition I have, and all of his ill-advised omissions and additions to the text have been reverted. Still, it is hard to believe any man could be as much of a jackass as Macaulay portrays him. Macaulay wholly justifies himself, however, when he complains that in Croker's comments, "We have 'fallacy' used as synonymous with 'falsehood.'" It warms my thistle-ish heart to hear someone who commits that gross solecism so savagely abused.

Macaulay animadverts against Boswell and Johnson as well. After saying that Boswell is the foremost biographer of all time, he strangely continues by calling Boswell the worst of men:

"We are not sure that there is in the whole history of the human intellect so strange a phænomenon as this book. Many of the greatest men that ever lived have written biography. Boswell was one of the smallest men that ever lived, and he has beaten them all. He was, if we are to give any credit to his own account or to the united testimony of all who knew him, a man of the meanest and feeblest intellect... Beauclerk used his name as a proverbial expression for a bore. He was the laughing-stock of the whole of that brilliant society which has owed to him the greater part of its fame... Servile and impertinent, shallow and pedantic, a bigot and a sot, bloated with family pride, and eternally blustering about the dignity of a born gentleman, yet stooping to be a talebearer, an eavesdropper, a common butt in the taverns of London... Without all the qualities which made him the jest and the torment of those among whom he lived, without the officiousness, the inquisitiveness, the effrontery, the toad-eating, the insensibility to all reproof he never could have produced so excellent a book."

Having read about halfway through, I think I can defend Boswell. Perhaps he becomes especially stupid later, but so far he seems like a guileless man of moderately good intelligence and much better education. His views on literature, where they differ from Johnson's, largely amount to agreeing with the dominant opinion of his time regarding each author, but he occasionally makes a good point. He does seem to have driven Johnson and others crazy at times, but he was pretty clearly a kind and good-natured man and only a little given to sycophancy. I was going to say that Macaulay might have been misled by the lack of celebrities and celebrity hangers-on in his day, but surely there are no worse sycophants than courtiers. The explanation for Macaulay's intense hatred of Boswell and considerable abuse of Johnson, is hinted at in these lines and explained in the Life. Macaulay says, "Of the talents which ordinarily raise men to eminence as writers, Boswell had absolutely none. There is not in all his books a single remark of his own on literature, politics, religion, or society, which is not either commonplace or absurd. His dissertations on hereditary gentility, on the slave-trade, and on the entailing of landed estates, may serve as examples."

And that is it. Macaulay was a fervent Whig, so a republican, an abolitionist, a hater of the old aristocracy, and in short the bitter enemy of Boswell (who was, after all, a Scottish nobleman) and of Johnson's politics, if not of Johnson himself. Both Boswell and Johnson often say things that would be intolerable if said now, and sometimes that were poorly reasoned, but it would be very foolish to judge what kind of men they were, by looking at what kind of men in the 19th or 21st century hold some opinions similar to theirs. A man who believes in the unmoving Earth in 1500 is not (without further evidence) the same sort of man as one who holds the same belief today.