Showing posts with label religion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label religion. Show all posts

Friday, December 5, 2008

Gervaise on religion

Ricky Gervaise, of The Office, preaches atheism, or at least the falseness of the Old Testament, through stand-up comedy. There are the usual objections: he is beating on an easy, harmless target instead of dangerous ones; he is attacking a minority (Old Testament literalists) among Christians; he does not know what he is talking about (saying he is "fine" with the New Testament when he rejects the Old Testament entirely); he is using his high status to abuse a low-status minority in front of audiences who loathe that minority; worst of all, he is being unfunny and calling it comedy. I wish I knew what hater of comedy first encouraged a stand-up comedian to pretend at thought.

Of course Gervaise is right that the Old Testament is substantially false as a record of fact, and even the historical books are full of errors. That bothered me quite a bit as I found out over the years just how extensively wrong the history is, but the things he makes fun of, like Noah's ark, either convert you to atheism on the spot as a child or in time stop feeling like questions of fact. That effect of a story losing the sense of facticity without undermining the worldview it helped build is a curious thing. Whatever the explanation, it is why tackling an adult Christian over Noah's ark is so futile; he has stopped believing that its truth value and relevance to his faith are connected to its facticity.

Most Christians are comfortable with assessing Biblical stories as myths, though many will refuse to use that word, since it implies affiliation with liberal theology and even outright spiritual disbelief. Instead the emphasis is on its true or inner meaning, that is, its mythical essence. Even the ones who feel obliged to defend its factual truth are, so to speak, fighting outside their borders; they can lose any number of scientific or engineering arguments without losing anything they really care about. A story that once supported a worldview has long since come to take its support from that worldview. Children in non-liberal churches are still taught the stories as written, which is a rather dishonest way of implying their factual truth and one I resent in hindsight, even if it is a little funny to think of a Sunday School teacher trying to present ideas about fact, truth, and myth to six-year-olds. It also cannot be over-emphasized how much contemporary Christians are ignorant, and disregarding, of the Old Testament, other than the chief Sunday School stories.

In none of his errors does Gervaise differ from the rest of the new atheist movement, but I want to point out something extraordinary he says in the Telegraph article:
I don't care if there are 50 per cent atheists or 75 per cent atheists in the world. I've got no problem with God being the most the popular thing in the world, with churches being filled, worship, no problem at all. People who believe in God that don't impinge on me, I don't care about. When it starts infringing on people and taking people's rights away that's a battle that's not going to be won by satirists or comedians. That's going to be won by governments saying: 'Ok you can worship what you like, but you are going to teach that evolution is the truth. You're going to tell them about matter and anti-matter and particle collision. Then you're going to say: Some people believe in the myth of Arthur and Santa Claus.' Religion is going to be lumped in with that. [emphasis added]
He is utterly incoherent in all the things I linked to, so it might be too much to expect him to mean what he seems to say, but then Sam Harris infamously wrote in Letter to a Christian Nation, "The link between belief and behavior raises the stakes considerably. Some propositions are so dangerous that it may be ethical to kill people for believing them. This may seem an extraordinary claim, but it merely enunciates an ordinary fact about the world in which we live." (Harris's defense.) Perhaps then Gervaise does mean it when he says that some other person teaching that evolution is false infringes on his rights. What a radical, what a totalitarian idea! This sick worldview, which is certainly Harris's if not Gervaise's, is why the new atheism must be resisted. As much as I love the discoveries of science, and even though I am not a believer, I would rather live among backwoods Pentacostals than grant the existence of a right over others' thoughts and words. Thank God for the First Amendment.

Monday, September 22, 2008

Off and on bended knee

There is a fine article in the NY Review of Books about science and religion. The topic is so thoroughly beaten out in so many bad articles and books that I can understand some reluctance to risk another, but this one, by Steven Weinberg, a physicist, is a fair-minded and highly educated account. It includes many references I have not seen before, like Melville's comment, "had [Emerson] lived in those days when the world was made, he might have offered some valuable suggestions," which sticks it right to that pious gasbag.

He also introduced me to Andrew Dickson White, Cornell's first president and a firm believer in the war of science and religion, and to al-Ghazzali, the Sufi philosopher who introduced into Islam the deranged notion that any natural law would be an abrogation of God's freedom. I once read about this idea, and tried to ask a Sufi guest speaker about it when I was at college, but managed to mangle the question, and since then had often wondered if I had even misunderstood the idea. Apparently not, which is a relief, and I am glad to have a name to go with it.

Looking at his other book reviews, it is clear that Prof. Weinberg is highly educated both in the humanities and in science, and he writes beautifully. It is a real pleasure to see that such a man could live today. He is 75, meaning he was educated in the old world that ended between 1963 and 1968, so his erudition cannot reassure me that much about the days to come. Still it is a fine sight and it is wonderful to be alive now while such things are yet possible.

Of course this is a blog, so even though his essay is as tranquil and clear as Crescent Lake, I am going to stick my oar in, catch crabs, and go about in circles with some criticism. He says,
When I was an undergraduate I knew a rabbi, Will Herberg, who worried about my lack of religious faith. He warned me that we must worship God, because otherwise we would start worshiping each other. He was right about the danger, but I would suggest a different cure: we should get out of the habit of worshiping anything.
Perhaps that would be best; it is hard to imagine a world without serious houses on serious ground, and sad. But set against the beautiful solemnity is a great deal of evil, as anyone can see in others' religions, so that if there could be no worship at all, we might all come out ahead. What I disagree with is the idea that that could happen. Religion is an enormous grab-bag of human passions, interests, and needs, as Steven Pinker, Prof. Weinberg, and Razib have all said, but if any single thing binds it all together, surely that is worship. Worship can be sweet silliness, like Amy Grant's early records, or a mysterious obligation, like the worship owed at every roadside shrine in Shintoism or ancient Greek religion, or pants-filling craziness, like Aztec sacrifices, but it necessarily embodies a recognition that the worshipper is less than he normally feels like, and that something else is more. Some religions, like Christianity, use a kind of jujitsu to flip the worshipper into the greatness he has just exalted, but the abasement of one and the exaltation of the other come first.

Well, then, what would be lost if humanity lost religion, learned not to worship? Of course there would be no foaming imams and Pat Robertson would have to sell cars, and we could all feel a lot safer from new Nazisms and Marxisms, so that would all be good. The rest would not be so great. So strong and universal an impulse as the desire to worship implies that it has a tremendous evolutionary advantage, and possibly other benefits as well that we may enjoy without any real gain in fitness. I think the chief evolutionary advantage is in enabling a non-hive species to achieve astounding works. One of the minor benefits may well be science itself, or at least scientists may benefit by enjoying what they do much more.

If the end of worship came about because men could no longer exalt any other entity, surely great enterprises would become very rare, perhaps impossible. Humans, even disaffected bookworms, do not treat their leaders, whether a small-time CEO or a generalissimo, as though they were only men. If they did so, respecting only the office but having no greater regard for its tenant, every command would grate, every plan would draw cavils, every competing idea would threaten group unity. It might be possible to start out with the conscious submission of will motivated by desire for the communal goal, but fissiparous reason will soon show a few men, then groups of men, then whole sects, that a "communal goal" is something of a fiction, especially when your leader is a blockheaded old goat who won't see reason. He always is, of course, being human.

Dalrymple would say that the end of abasement is more likely, and already in progress. Of course he lives in England, which from every account is suffering just what would be expected in an unworshipping land, as swollen egos collide in every interaction and no one sees a reason to give an inch of ground. Perhaps that is only among the less charming classes, but that means a large part of the country. Some men might be exalted, but not in a way that lets them unite men in a common cause; it is an ersatz worship. Nasty as the city would be, I think the wild would lose something as well. In part, nature's beauty derives its power from letting its intricacy, scale, age, willlessness relieve your heart of the self-regard that so painfully swells it. Would the unworshipping man feel any awe of the natural world? Life would be bleak without that awe, but science would suffer more. Every scientist, writing of his start in science, names some special aspect of nature which in one way or another overawed him and drew him into his life's course. Even if some of them are only fulfilling genre requirements, they seem sincere and many must be; surely few of them would have come to science without that experience, often renewed.

In the end, there will be worship, though we may exclude ourselves. Perhaps mankind should stop worshipping (if "should" really means anything), or least life might be quieter, but if I and you and Prof. Weinberg all stop, we have still changed nothing about the reality that made man a worshipper and that always will re-make him so. Yet if it is foolish and futile to hope for the end of religions and to encourage others to stop worshipping, it leaves a man like Prof. Weinberg stranded. The sensible unbeliever by nature would either accept that he is an aberration with little to say on this subject to normal humanity or else dedicate himself to ensuring that existing religions tame and civilize the religious impulse. The difficulty with the latter is that for any man to choose to worship because mankind must always worship, possibly accords with logic but is humanly irrational, and rather wicked, even if none of us can quite say why.